Over 7,000
money-saving tips!
Log In
Join
Site search:
Web Search:
Tips by Category:
 
Recent Popular Tips
3 Savvy and Successful Celebrity Moms >
6 Best Things to Buy in May >
7 Things You Should Always Buy New >
Super Grad Giveaway (Win a $100 Amazon Gift Card!) >
What NOT to Buy in May >
3 Tasty Ways to Use Up Leftover Wine >
Fabulous Birthday Freebies for 2013 >
Roundup: Most Popular Tips of April 2013 >
Tip Hero's First Free Ebook: An Ultimate Guide to Homemade Cleaners >
 
GIVEAWAYS SITES
Giveaways & Sweepstakes
 
Submit Your Own Tip!
Food & Dining Out
Home > Food & Dining Out > Topics:  Dining Out
Is a McDonald's "Value Meal" Really a Good Value?

Submitted by: Tip Hero  03/30/2009 10:16 AM
 
Next time you're at a fast-food restaurant and you're thinking of going with one of their "value meals" (or whatever they call them), think twice and make sure it really is a good deal.

McDonald's currently has a dollar menu where you can order a number of individual items for just one dollar. For example, you can order 4 Chicken McNuggets for $1. Get 8 for $2. 12 for $3. And so on.

One of their value meals (#10 at the McDonald's we visited) was for 10 Chicken McNuggets, an order of fries, and a soda. There were two prices listed. The lower price was $3.99. Turns out, this price is only for 10 Chicken McNuggets, and that the higher price ($6.39) includes the fries and the soda.

McDonald's is trying to sell 10 Chicken McNuggets for $4 through their value meal menu (which is, not suprisingly, front and center on their menu with big, pretty pictures of the meal), yet you can buy 8 for $2 or 12 for $3. Why would you ever buy 10 for $4? Doesn't make sense.

Value meals are quick and easy to order, and their name "value meal" (or similar) implies that they're a good deal. So it's easy to understand how consumers get tricked into ordering them. In some cases, they are good deals. But not always.

Furthermore, during this recent trip to McDonald's, we could not find the price for a hamburger, a cheeseburger or french fries anywhere on their menu. While we understand space is limited, it seemed to us like they were deliberately trying to hide the prices so you couldn't do the math to see whether it makes more sense to order a la carte or to go with a value meal.

Prices and menus at McDonald's vary by restaurant, so the above examples may not be the case elsewhere. In fact, we checked a McDonald's in another state and found different prices for the same value meals, and we also found examples where going a la carte made more sense than buying the value meal.

We don't mean to just pick on McDonald's here, as many other fast-food restaurants promote similar meal deals that aren't always the best value. But we do think it's a good idea to approach value meals at any restaurant with a bit of skepticism and make sure you're really getting a good deal.

Photo credit: AdamL212
---
sponsored: Find Free Grocery Coupons
---
Get free Tip Hero updates via Email, Facebook, or Twitter.
 
 
Comments:
 
.................................
 
Great observations. What's also incredible is the mark-up on these products.

A medium french fry costs well over a dollar but potatoes can be purchased in bulk for pennies.

Same thing goes for the soda. The $1.69 coke you pay for costs the restaurant about 25 cents in raw materials, a nearly 700% mark-up!

If you've taken a close look at a chicken McNugget there's not a lot of chicken there if you strip away the bread and batter.
 
Posted by Charlie-paylessforfood.com on April 01, 2009 7:39 PM
.................................
 
this is a very interesting article. However, if you want to save the most money in the long run chose to eat healthier options at mcdonalds. Try a salad with fat free dressing, apple dippers.. etc. Your savings on health related costs will outweigh short term savings for the dollar menu "chicken" nuggets
 
Posted by anonymous on April 02, 2009 10:12 AM
.................................
 
we only go to mcdonalds occasionally, and usually my children and i get a plain old cheeseburger... we actually went today for lunch. 3 cheeseburgers 3.16. i'm not a fan of happy meals either.. way too expensive.. oh and i have orange drink at home, along with pretzels..

but i agree with someone else, to save the most skip fast food
 
Posted by jessica jackson on April 02, 2009 2:10 PM
.................................
 
My sister has got me hooked on what she calls a "Baby Mac". She orders a double cheeseburger for $1 but gets lettuce & mac sauce on it (sometimes there is a small fee for that, but not always). It ends up being just as good a taste as the real Big Mac but less than half the cost!
 
Posted by Wani on April 02, 2009 4:09 PM
.................................
 
It just doesn't make sense to eat at McDonald's. Period. It's not food!
 
Posted by Janet on April 02, 2009 10:12 PM
.................................
 
Yep, it's not food. Better yet, pack a lunch or eat at home!
 
Posted by anonymous on April 03, 2009 1:54 PM
.................................
 
I like McDonalds once in awhile, and the dollar menu is the best deal. At any fast food restaurant, it's also a good idea to check the kid's meals. At Taco Bell, you get 2 tacos, nachos, and a soda. That's enough food for most adults!
 
Posted by anonymous on April 03, 2009 5:53 PM
.................................
 
First of all, you make one mistake on the issue of menu pricing. When you read the value menu pricing, the first price is for the item by itself and the second price is for the item with the fries and drink. It is a "value" because if you buy each item separately, it costs more than the "value" price offered. Every fast food restaurant does this.

As to another poster, double cheeseburgers are now $1.19 and are no longer on the $1 menu. The McDouble is on the dollar menu. It is the same as a double cheeseburger but it has one less slice of cheese (1 instead of 2). Most people still order the double cheeseburger not realizing this change.
 
Posted by Steve on April 04, 2009 3:04 PM
.................................
 
Here's a tip to get freshly-cooked burger every time... When you order your burger, ask for one condiment NOT to be added like ketchup, for example. Since the ones in the window are with everything, they have to cook you one fresh to make yours. You are much more likely to get a better, hotter burger this way. You can then always ask for ketchup on the side... ;)
 
Posted by anonymous on April 04, 2009 3:37 PM
.................................
 
Steve, I think the authors got it right. Just b/c it says VALUE meal doesn't mean it is, of course some of them are but I've foudn I just end up with a large coke that I can't drink, so I might have been better off ordering things individually. mcdonalds makes it hard to tell if it's a value b/c they don't post all of their prices and i htink they do this for a reason. if told it is a value meal, you instantly think, oh this is a better deal, b/c it says VALUE. I alwasy compare prices to make sure that it really is.

A $6.39 Value meal for 10 mcnuggets might not be a value if the cost of a large drink and a large fry is less than $3.89 (based on the $1 menu pricing of 4 nuggets for $1 or $0.25ea, so for 10 mcnuggets you should expect to pay $2.50 at a value price, which would mean that the coke and the fries combined would have to cost more than $3.89 to make this meal a value.)

i have also foudn that the dollar menus vary from store to store.
 
Posted by anonymous on April 05, 2009 9:57 AM
.................................
 
I agree, no nutrition really. Whether it's worth the money is a mute question in the end.
 
Posted by anonymous on April 06, 2009 2:50 AM
.................................
 
People saying McDonald's food has no nutritional value probably don't understand basic nutrition, and are just repeating what they've been told. There is actually a great deal of nutritional value in many of their items, they're just also very "calorie dense."
 
Posted by trlol on September 28, 2011 3:59 PM
.................................
 
"People saying McDonald's food has no nutritional value probably don't understand basic nutrition, and are just repeating what they've been told. There is actually a great deal of nutritional value in many of their items, they're just also very "calorie dense."

Posted by trlol on September 28, 2011 3:59 PM"

This comment makes the most sense out of all the rest of the comments! People saying it is not real food or it has no nutrition are just idiots repeating what they heard another person say. The ingredients are real food. The stuff is not made of plastic or sawdust. It does have nutritional value but it certainly isn't "health food". Using a regular McDonald's hamburger as an example :
Hamburger:
100% pure USDA inspected beef; no fillers, no extenders. Prepared with grill seasoning (salt, black pepper)., Regular Bun:
Enriched flour (bleached wheat flour, malted barley flour, niacin, reduced iron, thiamin mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid), water, high fructose corn syrup and/or sugar,
yeast, soybean oil and/or canola oil. Ketchup, Mustard, Pickle Slices, Onions. These are real food ingredients! Don't get me wrong, this isn't heart friendly health food. The hamburger is high in sodium, saturated fat, and calories but it still has nutritional value. It is high in protein, and supplies calcium, iron, and a small amount of fiber. This is something that should be eaten occasionally, not three times a day! Anything in excess is bad. You need to stop imitating other peoples words and think for yourself.
 
Posted by Ned Nedelander on April 19, 2012 3:04 PM
.................................
 
I couldn't even begin to tell you the last time I went to a McDonald's.. or any other fast food place , for that matter. I would rather make my own meals so I know exactly what is in them. I have never been a fan of fast food chains except for Subway. And the fact that farmers are now plumping and using chemicals to fatten up the beef, pork and chickens, for fast food consumption, I really don't want those chemicals in my body... If they are made to fatten up the animals, what is it doing to our bodies?? Maybe the FDA needs to do a study to find out if these chemicals are causing more obesity than what they first looked at the animals. What ever the animal eats, it's absorbed into the meat and when people eat it, the chemicals are still there...So who do we blame for obesity???
 
Posted by Brianna on April 26, 2012 4:34 PM
.................................
 
-----------------------------------------
Share Your Comments:
 
Comments may need to be approved before they are displayed.
 
Comments:
User Name (required):
Email Address (required - but your email address will not be displayed):
Website URL (not required; please do not include "http://"):