-
 
TipHero - Your Guide to Saving Money
Over 4,500
money-saving tips!
  
Log In
Become a Member
Web Search:   Site Search:
Tips by Category:
 
Recent Popular Tips
6 Things to Buy in May >
Share Your Suggestions for Website of the Week! >
Tip Hero's First Free Ebook: An Ultimate Guide to Homemade Cleaners >
10 Household Products We Overuse: How to Use Less and Save >
7+ Ways to Dress Up Boxed Mac & Cheese >
Roundup: Most Popular Tips of April 2012 >
14 Crafty Uses for Mesh Produce Bags >
Birthday Freebies for 2012 >
How to Save a Bundle When Booking Hotel Rooms >
 
GIVEAWAYS SITES
Giveaways & Sweepstakes
 
General
Home > General > Topics:  Misc
The Economics of Living Close to Family

Submitted by: anonymous  05/17/2009 11:17 AM
 
My wife and I grew up living near extended family, and so understand how living close to family can make life cheaper. However in our early marriage my employer transferred us couple of times, so that we lived no closer than twelve hours from relatives, and we felt the economic impact in a number of ways.

As soon as we were able, we moved back close to relatives and bought a home we hope to remain in for the remainder of our lives. But by then some relatives had passed away, and others had moved to other regions of the country, including my parents. Though we tried to visit, it was expensive to travel, trips were few, and we have watched our children grow up barely knowing most cousins and one set of grandparents. They have almost no emotional bond with long-distance relatives, as compared to the relatives who lived close.

Over the years, I have been mystified to watch retirees pull up stakes and move to Florida, leaving their grandchildren behind. I have also observed other parents encourage their children to take on glamorous long-distance ventures, such as being foreign-exchange students, and going to colleges on the other side of the country.

I know two of these exchange students who married people they met in these foreign countries. One never moved back to the U.S. and the other now regularly takes costly trips back to Europe to see her family. The same happens with students who go to far away colleges: they often meet and marry people who live far away, or find employment near those colleges, and never return home.

None of our children ever expressed a desire to travel, and neither did we encouraged it. Instead, as our children grew up we talked to them often about the potential long-term benefits of ultimately settling close to their parents. Even if they might be enriched by long-distance ventures, there is a trade off. If they move away for a higher-paying job, I pointed out how this increased pay could be offset by the economic disadvantages of living far from relatives. But even more, I want my children and grandchildren to be enriched by the bond that happens when they live near each other. Those relationships will be important to them long after my wife and I are gone.

The economic benefits of living close are many. My grown children regularly avail themselves of the numerous skills and resources my wife and I have acquired over the decades. We have built or repaired their furniture, shared garden produce, loaned our cars when theirs was being repaired, done complex sewing, rescued them when their cars died in the middle of nowhere or in the middle of the night, offered free baby sitting, loaned tools, carpooled, found items for them at yard sales, etc. One can, of course do much the same with close friends, but likely never really to the same degree as one can with family.

I know that the relationships between parents and grown children do not always work smoothly. As parents we had to learn to stop parenting grown children, and instead treat them with the same respect and boundaries that we could treat a non-relative friend. It also means that we do not repeatedly bail them out for making poor choices (so far, not a problem). We do not allow them to mooch or take advantage of us. We refrain from offering uninvited advice as well, except in cases of things such as safety.

I regard helping grown children to be like putting pennies in a bank, as I know at some point in the distance future, I or my wife might want to remove some of those pennies. In the case of my grandparents, my wife and I often provided labor that enabled her to stay in her home (and out of a nursing home) for much longer than had she no area relatives. We did yard work, house painting, drove her to appointments, stacked her firewood, stayed with her when she was sick and so on. I wanted to do these things for her because she did so much for me growing up.

Our culture has become so transient and disconnected, that we have forgotten this obvious frugal strategy.

Photo credit: deltaMike
---
sponsored: Find Free Grocery Coupons
---
Get free Tip Hero updates via Email,
Facebook, or Twitter.
          
 
 
 
 
 
 
Comments:
 
.................................
 
I see your point, but at the same time, there is so much to experience in life outside of the town where you grew up. Ultimately, I did come back to live within an hour of family, but I wouldn't trade all I learned while living all over the country.

That being said, I don't know how people raise kids without family nearby. Nice to not always have to pay for a babysitter!
 
Posted by anonymous on May 21, 2009 2:09 PM
.................................
 
Amen!! Thank you so much for this article. My parents decided they wanted to live on a resort island and moved away. I'm glad they enjoy it (minus the financial impact they deal with to live there)but miss the close, helpful family you discuss here. Thankfully, I also have lots of siblings and only a few decided to move to other places. I miss my parents and am sorry not to have my children know them.
 
Posted by anonymous on May 21, 2009 8:59 PM
.................................
 
I live close to my mother and in-laws. I agree there are so many benefits of living close. My children have a very close relationships with both my mother and my in-laws. My father decided to move to Flordia and does not get to see my children as often...only about 2 times per year. They are definately not close to my father. When my step mother passed away, we were able to get down to Florida within a day but still it is hard to be so far away.

As my mother and my in-laws age, it is nice to know we are close to make sure we are around for any doctor's appointment and any help around the house. When my kids were younger, they were always there when I needed a babysitter. It is a nice tradeoff. I think my husband and I would have had a much harder time living far from family. Of course, the time we spend with our family is the biggest benefit. We will definately always cherish the many, many memories we have made with our parents.
 
Posted by anonymous on May 24, 2009 4:55 PM
.................................
 
I think that the argument that one becomes enriched by living in different places is less true than it was a generation ago. I lived in a major city for more than a decade, and have traveled all over the U.S. for business, doing a profession most people would think is glamorous. My kids grew up in a town with fewer than 2500 people and went to community colleges. They all still live close enough to visit every week. As young adults, they are more sophisticated than I was at their age, though I had gone to "bigger places." I think maybe the Internet is the difference.
 
Posted by anonymous on May 24, 2009 8:35 PM
.................................
 
To my parents the mantra and biggest goal for their kids was to be independent. There was no option to "stay home." My parents have no desire for us to be in the same area nor to help in any way. I think my mother would like if we were within driving distance for special occasions, but in no way to help us. I so wish I had my family to help, as my 3 children are tough to handle at times alone. I would love to adopt some grandparents....but I think that generation is not so keen on helping out. My parents are just as happy to be wrapped up in their own activities and lives. They don't even have time for any friends. It's sad. I long for the good ole days sometimes.......when extended family supported each other.!
 
Posted by anonymous on May 26, 2009 7:31 PM
.................................
 
I love this post! I am in my mid sixties and have always lived in the same area as has my family for 5 generations. I do not understand why families do not help each other out. I live within 5 miles of my 5 brothers and sisters. One of my children and 2 grandchildren live with me. My other child is 4 miles away. I help them as I can but an added benefit of staying put is seeing my high school friends every day or so. We go to the Y, eat out and take mini-vactions together.

When I meet people who move with their jobs..it seems bizare to me. They try to live their lives through the schools their children attend..because they know nobody. They are referred to as helicoptor parents because they are always circling their kids. Thus their children do not mature as they should. Its a crazy cycle.....one I am glad I am not in!
 
Posted by spidermonkey on May 28, 2009 6:00 PM
.................................
 
I like the Dr. Laura-ism: "You don't get to pick your first family, but you get to pick your second family." So if you don't like the family that you got born into, create the one you want your children and grandchildren to have. Be smart in picking a spouse, if possible settle into one house early in the marriage and stay there (so kids feel rooted), invest time in your children, and start traditions unique to your family. Then as they grow up and start moving out, with deliberateness, set up situations to attract adult children to return home regularly.

I began to see my family spin off into different directions before kids started moving out. It got increasingly difficult to get everyone together for even one meal a week, as everyone had different work schedules, sports schedules and outside social lives.

After the first two moved out I decided we needed to make an effort to be close, or everyone would start drifting off. It took some doing, including strong-arming hubby to juggle his part-time-job work schedule, but we finally started a tradition of having a special meal every Sunday night. It was an immediate success, as most kids come most weeks. We treat this night as a little sacred, asking family members to schedule their social lives for any night of the week other than Sunday night.

In addition to family members, significant others come, as do occasional friends. We have sometimes had as many as a dozen people for a meal.

Since one daughter has to drive 45 minutes to come, to offset her gas costs, we let her do her laundry here, and even (horrors) allow her to use our dryer. We sometimes send kids home with garden produce and other food items.

Because kids travel to come, to also make it worth their while, I stepped up the meals, each week trying to do something special. We have tried many new recipes, but also have done requested family favorites. I also do a dessert with each meal, which is a new thing for us. It isn't fancy every week, but often I find something that is surprising and special. In the 14 months since we started doing Sunday suppers, I have never repeated a dessert, and repeated only a few main dishes.

We sometimes combine this dinner with other activities, such as watching a DVD, playing cards or some outdoor game. If there is a birthday we celebrate it Sunday night.

I always plan the meals, but my husband and I share the cooking. I always wash the dishes, with the help of one at-home daughter, so that no traveling kid is asked to help. At some point I expect the work load will be shared, but for now I am willing to do most of the work, to make this happen.

I can't claim this is a save-money idea, as it is not cheap to feed so many. It's really an investment in the future of us as a family.






 
Posted by anonymous on May 30, 2009 9:25 AM
.................................
 
I live in a multi-generational setting & love it. We moved back home five years ago & it was probably the BEST decision we ever made. We share a driveway (and mailbox) with my hubby's parents & his grandfather (his grandmother passed away two years after we moved home). My sons have an amazing relationship as a result with both their great-grandfather & their paternal grandparents. We are truly blessed to be here.
 
Posted by Lisa on June 21, 2009 9:12 PM
.................................
 
My husband and I could not have survived his college years if it were not for the fact that we lived in the same town as his parents. There are so many ways that my in laws have helped us keep afloat, from buying food, lending money, even giving us a car (abet used) when one was totaled.

We too have a tradition of having a weekly meal. Recent research shows that having a weekly or monthly meal with family and friends can increase your life span and well being. It lowers blood pressure, increases family connections and helps young children's development. Plus they can be really fun!
 
Posted by anonymous on July 10, 2009 12:10 PM
.................................
 
Although I understand WHY you don't encourage travel with your children, I cannot imagine taking the same approach with my own.

My husband left West Africa to study in Quebec, I left Alberta to study in Quebec, and there we met. It means that neither of us are super close to our families but how could I ever wish I hadn't met my husband (or had our beautiful children together)?

Also, traveling has other advantages such as opening our eyes to the beauty of other cultures and people groups, exploring God's amazing creation, helping us see, firsthand the living conditions of others which can motivate us/our kids to make healthier choices in our own lives, etc.

Having said all that, I'd love to have family involved in our lives to a much larger degree. We work at creating strong relationships with other families but this will never be the same as genuine family ties.
 
Posted by Kika on July 26, 2009 3:30 PM
.................................
 
being a military family I agree with everyone.. I love the travel of seeing different cultures and teaching our 4 children to appreciate others for who they are.. but in the same respect we are fighting to get orders just so we can be relocated close to family..

when my husband was out for the year it was his family that put a roof over our heads and helped to make sure our children had food.. even a few doctors didn't charge us an office visit ( a few really) because we needed doc papers to re-join the military.

but now stationed over 4,000 miles away I miss them dearly and the small town life pertraded in this article.. so much my husband and I believe that its very important to know the grandparents and in our case the great grandparents that the family (myself and kids) may actually head back home early to wait on my husband because he will be deployed again to iraq and during that time he is gone we are scheduled to relocate..

currently he is deployed now and for the past 10 months I've raised my 4 young children (oldest is 6 years old) alone, was diagnosed with Fibromyalgia, had a daughter diagnosed with mild autism, and broke a bone in my foot that wasn't suppose to be there to begin with... long run.. if I had been home during this deployment I wouldn't have had to do all the above alone..
 
Posted by anonymous on September 24, 2009 2:16 AM
.................................
 
I know some people have very difficult families so I can understand the need for space. What I can't figure out is why people who claim to love each other pick up and move hundreds or thousands of miles away for reasons that don't seem very important.I would never move away and lose all those wonderful moments together. I want to live close to the people that I love,not just see them a couple times year.
 
Posted by anonymous on October 20, 2009 10:12 PM
.................................
 
There are a lot of reasons you might need to move far away from your family. My husband went to grad school in California, leaving behind his family in Indiana. Staying closer to home would have meant turning down Cal Tech. Then he moved out to the East Coast to be with me, so he is still hundreds of miles from Indiana (though much closer than he was before). Also, people in certain careers might have to move to another state or lose their jobs (a big problem in the current economy). So you have to consider all the factors--what you can gain by staying near home, and what you can gain by being somewhere else.
 
Posted by haverwench on January 03, 2010 8:55 AM
.................................
 
-----------------------------------------
Share Your Comments:
 
Comments may need to be approved before they are displayed.
 
Comments:
User Name (required):
Email Address (required - but your email address will not be displayed):
Website URL (not required; please do not include "http://"):
 
 
 
 
-